A few days ago, Tanya Dixon-Neely came under fire and was suspended from her job as a North Carolina Teacher for comments some say were out of context, incorrect, and bully like to students. If you have not heard the news, Tanya Dixon-Neely is an obvious supporter of President Obama. She is passionate, and she is supportive. However, the point I want to make about this incident in a public school, is something that many Republicans, of which I am not, and Independents, of which I am, are feeling these days when it comes to free speech and the right of opinion in America. There may exist a double standard when it comes to criticizing a Democrat versus a Republican.
In 2008, I stood in my polling booth with a ballot that was 99% completed. I had to make one final choice, and that was between McCain and Obama for President of the United States. I honestly stood there for quite some time thinking of who I would choose. I was not sure for many days leading up to the election as to who I would cast my vote for. I was hearing all kinds of negative ads from McCain and Obama insulting each other with paid political advertisements. I was inundated with phone calls from computers playing pre recorded messages from McCain and Obama, and I was even more than tired of seeing the highways and the byways covered with a gazillion political signs one after the other after the other, after the other. It was enough to make you want to close your eyes and flip a coin. In the end I choose Obama. I said to myself, I will give you a chance to come through on the things you said you would do.
I am not writing about the things Obama has done or not done since then. I am writing because I think that there is a general misconception of political adversity in America and I hopefully we can talk about it and not shout about it without making any conclusions made that would be as in error as the statements of Tanya Dixon-Neely to her class. The trouble with Tanya Dixon-Neely is that she is really not all that wrong about slander speech regarding a President. To say President Obama is a liar is slanderous. Yet, millions do this every day, just as millions of people call George Bush I & II liars. There is some truth to this. Now, looking closely at the slander laws for the United States, you will fine this clip from nearly any slander defense and description web page:
“The common law traditionally presumed that a statement was false once a plaintiff proved that the statement was defamatory. Under modern law, a plaintiff who is a public official or public figure must prove falsity as a prerequisite for recovery. Some states have likewise now provided that falsity is an element of defamation that any plaintiff must prove in order to recover. Where this is not a requirement, truth serves as an affirmative defense to an action for libel or slander. A statement does not need to be literally true in order for this defense to be effective. Courts require that the statement is substantially true in order for the defense to apply. This means that even if the defendant states some facts that are false, if the “gist” or “sting” of the communication is substantially true, then the defendant can rely on the defense.”
Hunter Rodgers asked specifically if Obama bullied a girl in his days as a youth, after Tanya Dixon-Neely discussed the bully situation with Mitt Romney. Ok, so far so good – we have a squash here. Both have and both did each according to their own admissions; case closed, move on, but no.
Here is where the bias may be something folks should look at. Now I will say that I can see and understand the position of white or European-Americans when it comes to stating opinions that are not supportive of President Obama. In fact, as I have talked to some young voters, they feel afraid to mention anything negative about Obama, or anyone connected to him that is black or African-American. To say my brother is not a fan of either President Bush would be the understatement of the year. To say that I am a fan of President Obama would be true and false at the same time. My brother will tell you flat out that you must be a rich person and love big oil if you are a Republican. That is his opinion, and I love him for his passion on that. Still others I talk to hate Obama and will tell you so at any chance they get. However, if the subject of race comes up, the theme changes immediately.
This needs to stop, and it stops with YOU.
In this Dantastic world I urge all people, black, white, brown, red, yellow, etc… Respect the difference of opinion we have, and let us not shout down students in class rooms because they something that is factual, but personally you think is slanderous. Rather let us instill upon our news sources that the race cards and the socio-economic ploys that each one, (CNN, FOX, MSNBC, ETC) use to attract viewers needs to end NOW! Stop playing whites against blacks, rich against poor, and haves verse have not’s
I leave you with solution of action:
Teacher, which is the greatest commandment in the Law?” Jesus replied: “‘Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with your entire mind.’ This is the first and greatest commandment. And the second is like it: ‘Love your neighbor as yourself.’ All the Law and the Prophets hang on these two commandments.”





